Barbastro clings to the ecclesiastical judgments i
Barbastro clings to the ecclesiastical judgments in civil proceedings Strip Art.
Verse of San Mateo "no one can serve God and money" put an end to the argument of counsel in the Aragon, Hipolito Gomez of Roces, who denied the figure of the usucapion to the Association of Friends of the Museum of Lleida attempt to show in the first civil trial because of this, that 87 works belong to the diocese of Lleida., buy kinah,
A lawyer's continued rrences to Case Aragonese the Apostolic Signatura, 2007 favorable to the delivery of works to Aragon, the curator of the Museum of Lleida, Tarragona priest Jesus answer: "But here is worth."
He said in clear rrence to what was discussed today was not the ecclesiastical law, but ownership of the pieces in civil law. Nor is judged whether, tera gold, these pieces must be in Lleida or Barbastro.
The trial held in the Hearing Room of Lleida by the Court of Instruction number 4 still is not seen for sentencing. There remains the decision of the judge of whether or not, at the request of the lawyer of the Diocese of Lleida, the Court of Justice, gods and heroes gold, of Catalunya (TSJC) at the end of 2008 dismissed the appeals by the Deputation and the diocese of Lleida against the decision issued in April 2006 by the Councillor for Culture Caterina Mieras which denied the possibility of moving the work to Aragon.
Include affidavits of acquisitions made by the Bishop Josep Messeguer to 1905 to show that the diocese owns the Catalan art was another of the requests of counsel for the diocese of Lleida, Xavier Gonzalo.
To silence voices critical of the current bishop, Joan Piris, for failing to return the works, counsel center much of their intervention to clarify the intention Piris if you have to respect the decisions of ecclesiastical obedience and has been the Ministry of Culture who has prevented protected in law Catalan heritage.
The complaint was lodged by the Association of Friends of the Museum of Lleida against the diocese of Lleida in order to judge the ownership of the works, using the figure of the usucapion, peaceful possession, publishes and parts continued for six years if not There are titles of ownership.
"It's been twenty times and half the time lordship", affirmed the counsel for the association Francesc Sapena, that argument is based on his thesis, explaining the money that was spent by the diocese to preserve the pieces and I quote as the recent case law decision of the Hearing Seville in which two brotherhoods were in litigation.
Sapena, pointing out that today is International Museum Day, the Vatican reminded the decision not to hand over the works that claimed an Italian church in favor of maintaining the collection.
The attorney for the Diocese of Barbastro devoted little time to discuss the usucapion strongly arguing the Diocese of Lleida never owned the pieces, but was the custodian. "The Apostolic Signatura if anyone says that does not have a landlord may usurcapir title.
You did not attend the requirement of continued good faith belief that canon law requires in all cases and not even initially exisitio. "He said more: If not taken as disrespectful, so I do not want to say, I would say that the lack of good faith is the original sin that affects this alleged usucapion. "
Gomez reminded the the Bishop RocesLleida usucapion waive all when I answer to the complaint, as Bishop Xavier Salinas, a circumstance that now from his point of view can not be changed by the fact that a new bishop and a new lawyer.
He also argued that Pablo Picasso's Guernica has spent more than half a century many foreign museums, and has continued to be owned by the Spanish State. "And finally, it is not like usucapion usurpation" he said.
Before issuing a trial, the judge must also resolve whether the association or not claimant is entitled to raise the demand on the part of the documentary evidence records that served as the bishop of Lleida in 1943 to recover items that had been kept in Zaragoza during the Civil War.
"I declare under oath to be fond of Glorious Movement, and also the legitimate owner of these objects." Thus began the records kept at the Institut d'Estudis Ilerdencs (IEI) with which the association wanted to assert today that the Diocese of Lleida has had these parts in stock and property.
The decision to hold the trial in the hall of the Provincial Court was due to the enormous interest in the hearing to the public attended the president of the Diputaci??n de Lleida, Jaume Gilabert Republican, Vice President, Gabriel Pena and director of IEI, Albert Turull, and the director of the Diocesan Museum of Lleida, Montserrat Macia.